Redundancy ends with the pilot

Peter Garrison – Although SS1 was a novel design with an untried type of motor and was venturing into inhospitable territory last visited by the X-15 almost 50 years earlier, the privately funded programme progressed with speed and smoothness that were a credit to Rutan himself and to the talents of the team of engineers and pilots he had assembled.

Pater Garrison.

DURING 18 MONTHS in 2003 and 2004, SpaceShipOne, Scaled Composites’ original air-launched spaceplane, made 14 free flights of which six were powered, the rest glides. Although a few potentially life-threatening problems arose, the programme ended without mishap and gained the $10 million Ansari X Prize, for which it was, in fact, the only realistic competitor. The reported program cost, met by Microsoft co-founder Paul Allen, was $25 million.

At Scaled Composites, the SS1 program went by the name Tier 1, the first of several “tiers” that represented, metaphorically, a staircase out of this world. Tier 1 meant suborbital flight just past the “edge of space,” arbitrarily defined as 100 km or about 62 miles above the earth.

Rutan had grander visions, however, and spoke of orbiting hotels and “affordable” tourist trips to the moon. Privately-funded manned orbital flight was to be Tier 2, and everything beyond low Earth orbit was Tier 3.

The steps, however, were of different sizes. Tier1 required speeds on the order of Mach 3, or around 2,000 mph. Injecting something into low earth orbit requires 17,000 mph and escape from the gravitational field of the earth requires 25,000 mph. Attaining those higher speeds is exponentially more difficult, as is decelerating from them while re-entering the atmosphere.

‘propelled by laughing gas and tyre rubber’

On the Tier 1 to Tier 3 scale, the step from the three-person SS1 to a larger copy carrying half a dozen paying passengers to the same height appears practically trivial. Tier 1b, commonly known as SpaceShipTwo, is a scaled-up and restyled version of SS1. The technology is proven. There are some significant changes, notably the switch from a high to a low wing and a much sleeker “look” – the watermelon-shaped SS1 was rather homely – but the essentials, including the so-called “hybrid” rocket engine and the novel “feather” system for dissipating energy during the descent, remain the same.

Nevertheless, SS2 development has dragged on for a decade and a half, its slowness paradoxically underscored by Virgin Galactic founder Richard Branson’s repeated public assurances that the first launch of would-be “space tourists” – 700 of whom had signed up at $250,000 apiece – was right around the corner. That launch finally occurred in September, 2021, shortly followed by an announcement that, because of undisclosed problems, no further flights would occur for at least eight months.

‘mishaps could occur in ways and at times nobody anticipated’

There were several reasons for the slow pace of progress. One was that carrying passengers required a much lower tolerance for risk. Rutan himself, who for health reasons ceased to have a leading role a few years into the programme, warned that commercial space flight could not be as safe as airline travel; but Scaled engineers felt morally and professionally obliged to make it as safe as they could. A deadly oxidiser explosion in 2007, during an ostensibly innocuous ground test, drove home the lesson that mishaps could occur in ways and at times that nobody anticipated. The self-imposed discipline of engineering SS2 came to resemble a certification program, even though the FAA was not involved and there is not yet anything like a Part 23 for spacecraft.

The principal cause of delay, however, was the hybrid rocket engine, which turned out not to scale well. Much had been made, during the X Prize days, of the fact that SS1 was propelled by “laughing gas and tyre rubber.” The implication was that the engine was not delicate and temperamental, but very primitive and simple and just about bulletproof.

Scaled had cast the motor’s solid-propellant cores in-house with reasonable success, but they were still prone to uneven burning and unnerving thrust fluctuations. These problems proved to be more severe on SS2, which required 75,000 pounds of thrust to SS1’s 18,000. It had to produce that thrust for about 80 seconds, but the longest in-flight burn attempted so far on one of SS2’s rubber-based engines was 18 seconds.

Finally Scaled switched to a different fuel formulation, commonly described as a plastic resembling nylon, which was said to be more powerful and better-behaved and to have performed well in ground tests. An October 31, 2014 flight, whose purpose was examine feathered behaviour at supersonic speed, was to be its first airborne test.

Virgin Galactic’s spaceship Unity glides over the Mojave Air and Space Port in California during a May 1, 2017 test flight.

‘depend on the pilots to fly correctly’

The “feather” system consists simply of a hinge running across the wing at around 70 percent of chord. It allows the entire spaceplane to jack-knife, raising the nose and the fore part of the wing so that they present a bluff surface to the air. The lift/drag ratio drops by a factor of more than 10 and the craft stabilises in a very steep descent with the fuselage more or less horizontal and the tail surfaces and their supporting booms aligned with the direction of flight. Once the spaceplane enters sufficiently dense air, it unfolds back to a normal configuration and glides to a conventional landing. What is remarkable about the system is that it is equally stable at subsonic and supersonic speeds. It has even been used, on one occasion, to recover from an inadvertent flat spin.

At supersonic speed, because the centre of lift of the wing shifts aft, the aerodynamic force on the tail surfaces is downward. Earlier in a flight, however, when the centre of gravity is behind the centre of lift because of the weight of the as yet unburned fuel, aerodynamic forces at high subsonic speed lift the tail with sufficient leverage to overpower the pneumatic actuators. A separate locking system is therefore required to preclude premature feathering.

In SS1, the pilot would never unlock the feather system until the engine burn had ended. In the highly unlikely event that the feather failed to unlock, SS1 would have had to make a dangerous, but probably successful, gliding re-entry. In the heavier SS2, an unfeathered re-entry would have involved higher speeds and looked too chancy for paying passengers.

A new flight protocol was consequently introduced. When the speed reached Mach 1.4, about 25 seconds after release from the mother ship, the pilot would call for unlock and the copilot would perform the action. If the feather failed to unlock, the engine would be shut down immediately and the spaceplane would coast back without the need for a Mach 3 re-entry.

This procedure appeared safe. What no one could anticipate was that the copilot, for reasons that are not understood and probably never will be, would unlock the feather at Mach 0.8. This was an eventuality against which no redundancy had been provided. It was unimaginable.

‘the speed reached Mach1.4, about 25 seconds after release‘

But the unimaginable happened. The tail rotated and the spacecraft pitched up with extreme violence. The motor broke away from the oxidiser tank, the airframe disintegrated. The pilots, first crushed down by enormous positive G, were then flung out in their seats as the top of the fuselage tore away. Some piece of structure struck the copilot, killing him; the pilot, one shoulder broken, fell for more than a minute through intense cold, without oxygen, but came to in time to unbuckle his seat belts. As his seat fell away his parachute, set to deploy automatically at 14,500 feet, opened. A chase plane came to look at him; he gave it a thumbs-up with his good arm.

While the FAA, as the regulator of atmospheric flight, issues launch licenses to operators of commercial space vehicles, it is barred by a piece of Reagan-era legislation from interfering in their technical development. The idea was to allow the technology to evolve naturally, like that of early airliners, before codifying a set of certification standards for passenger-carrying spacecraft. A later law, the Commercial Space Launch Amendments Act of 2004, permits the FAA to step in if an in-flight fatality occurs. The October 31 accident was the first such fatality in commercial space flight, and the FA did exercise its right to demand a number of modifications to the design.

It might seem simple enough to add a system to prevent feather unlock at subsonic speed during motor burn. But that system would have its own failure modes, and would require its own increasingly complex backups – and on and on. In the end, what is true in atmospheric flight also holds true in space: You have to depend on the pilots to fly correctly, even if every now and then one of them may make some catastrophic mistake.

The NTSB inspects the wreckage of SpaceShip 2 after its inadvertent fold.

235 Comments

  1. http://indiapharm.guru/# indian pharmacies safe
    india pharmacy mail order [url=https://indiapharm.guru/#]cheapest online pharmacy india[/url] indian pharmacies safe

  2. http://canadapharm.top/# canadianpharmacymeds com
    buying prescription drugs in mexico [url=https://mexicopharm.shop/#]reputable mexican pharmacies online[/url] mexican mail order pharmacies

  3. Vardenafil buy online [url=http://levitra.icu/#]Buy Levitra 20mg online[/url] Buy Vardenafil 20mg

  4. Levitra 10 mg best price [url=http://levitra.icu/#]Buy Vardenafil 20mg[/url] Levitra 10 mg buy online

  5. Levitra online pharmacy [url=https://levitra.icu/#]Levitra online USA fast[/url] п»їLevitra price

  6. buy generic tadalafil [url=http://tadalafil.trade/#]tadalafil otc usa[/url] buy tadalafil online australia

  7. buy kamagra online usa [url=http://kamagra.team/#]п»їkamagra[/url] buy kamagra online usa

  8. ciprofloxacin order online [url=https://ciprofloxacin.men/#]ciprofloxacin without insurance[/url] ciprofloxacin 500 mg tablet price

  9. buy doxycycline 100mg capsules online [url=https://doxycycline.forum/#]buy doxycycline over the counter[/url] doxycycline online for dogs

  10. amoxicillin price canada: amoxil for sale – amoxicillin over the counter in canada

  11. zithromax online pharmacy canada [url=http://azithromycin.bar/#]zithromax antibiotic[/url] zithromax for sale cheap

  12. purchase lisinopril 10 mg [url=https://lisinopril.auction/#]buy lisinopril[/url] lisinopril generic price comparison

  13. zithromax 250 price [url=https://azithromycin.bar/#]buy zithromax[/url] zithromax canadian pharmacy

  14. lisinopril 5mg pill [url=https://lisinopril.auction/#]buy lisinopril online[/url] lisinopril cost

  15. mexican pharmacies online [url=http://ordermedicationonline.pro/#]order medication online[/url] canadian drug stores

  16. purple pharmacy mexico price list: mexican pharmacy – mexico drug stores pharmacies

  17. pharcharmy online no script [url=https://buydrugsonline.top/#]buy drugs online safely[/url] top rated online pharmacies

  18. https://gabapentin.life/# price of neurontin
    ventolin online australia [url=http://claritin.icu/#]cheap ventolin inhalers[/url] ventolin australia buy

  19. п»їfarmacia online migliore: kamagra gold – п»їfarmacia online migliore

  20. farmacia online internacional [url=http://vardenafilo.icu/#]Levitra 20 mg precio[/url] farmacia online madrid

  21. farmacia barata [url=http://tadalafilo.pro/#]tadalafilo[/url] farmacia online internacional

  22. п»їfarmacia online [url=https://tadalafilo.pro/#]cialis en Espana sin receta contrareembolso[/url] farmacias online seguras

  23. farmacia barata [url=https://farmacia.best/#]farmacia online envio gratis murcia[/url] farmacias online seguras en espaГ±a

  24. п»їfarmacia online [url=https://kamagraes.site/#]kamagra gel[/url] farmacia 24h

  25. farmacia envГ­os internacionales [url=https://farmacia.best/#]farmacias online seguras[/url] farmacias online baratas

  26. farmacia online 24 horas [url=http://vardenafilo.icu/#]Precio Levitra En Farmacia[/url] farmacias online seguras en espaГ±a

  27. п»їfarmacia online [url=https://farmacia.best/#]farmacia envio gratis[/url] farmacia online envГ­o gratis

  28. farmacia barata [url=http://kamagraes.site/#]se puede comprar kamagra en farmacias[/url] farmacias online seguras en espaГ±a

  29. Acheter mГ©dicaments sans ordonnance sur internet [url=http://pharmacieenligne.guru/#]pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance[/url] п»їpharmacie en ligne

  30. Viagra homme sans ordonnance belgique [url=https://viagrasansordonnance.store/#]Viagra sans ordonnance 24h[/url] Viagra homme prix en pharmacie sans ordonnance

  31. Pharmacies en ligne certifiГ©es [url=https://pharmacieenligne.guru/#]pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance[/url] Pharmacie en ligne France

  32. Pharmacie en ligne livraison rapide [url=http://kamagrafr.icu/#]kamagra livraison 24h[/url] Pharmacie en ligne livraison gratuite

  33. Pharmacie en ligne pas cher [url=https://kamagrafr.icu/#]kamagra livraison 24h[/url] Acheter mГ©dicaments sans ordonnance sur internet

  34. Pharmacie en ligne pas cher: achat kamagra – Pharmacie en ligne France

  35. top 10 pharmacies in india indian pharmacy – cheapest online pharmacy india indiapharmacy.guru

  36. reputable canadian online pharmacy canada ed drugs – pharmacy com canada canadiandrugs.tech

  37. п»їerectile dysfunction medication ed treatment pills – ed medications online edpills.tech

  38. An outstanding share! I have just forwarded this onto a friend who was doing a little homework on this.
    And he actually bought me breakfast simply because I stumbled
    upon it for him… lol. So allow me to reword this….

    Thanks for the meal!! But yeah, thanx for spending time to talk
    about this issue here on your internet site.

  39. zithromax online pharmacy canada [url=https://azithromycin.store/#]cheapest azithromycin[/url] generic zithromax 500mg india

  40. where can i buy zithromax uk [url=https://azithromycin.store/#]Azithromycin 250 buy online[/url] generic zithromax medicine

  41. п»їfarmacia online migliore [url=http://tadalafilitalia.pro/#]Dove acquistare Cialis online sicuro[/url] farmacia online

  42. comprare farmaci online con ricetta: kamagra oral jelly – comprare farmaci online con ricetta

  43. the canadian drugstore [url=https://canadapharm.shop/#]reddit canadian pharmacy[/url] canadian pharmacy world

  44. La compatibilité du logiciel de suivi mobile est très bonne et il est compatible avec presque tous les appareils Android et iOS. Après avoir installé le logiciel de suivi sur le téléphone cible, vous pouvez afficher l’historique des appels du téléphone, les messages de conversation, les photos, les vidéos, suivre la position GPS de l’appareil, activer le microphone du téléphone et enregistrer l’emplacement environnant.

  45. best online pharmacies without a script: online drugs – online pharmacy with no prescription

  46. Tant qu’il y a un réseau, l’enregistrement en temps réel à distance peut être effectué sans installation matérielle spéciale.

  47. Cherry Gold Casino is giving away 150% Welcome Bonus … İl Emniyet Müdürlüğü’nde görevli 21 polis müdürü ve emniyet amiri başka illere tayin edilirken 7 emniyet müdürü ile 5 emniyet amiri İstanbul’a atandı İl Emniyet Müdürlüğü’nde görevli 21 polis müdürü ve emniyet amiri başka illere tayin edilirken 7 emniyet müdürü ile 5 emniyet amiri İstanbul’a atandı Promotion of the Month: 275% Slots bonus + 25 Spins on Epic Holiday Party slot game on deposits of $100+ and using bonus code ‘CASINOALONE’. And then, 200% Slots Bonus + 45 Spins on Vegas Lux on the next deposit of $85+ using bonus code ‘WETBANDITS’. Bonus valid to play slots and specialty games only. The wagering requirement is 30x and there is no maximum cash out. T&C apply.
    https://telegra.ph/find-free-poker-games-07-06
    Joka Room casino launched in 2018 and is licensed by the government of Curacao. It is owned by Viral Technology N.V. and available in no download instant play for mobile and desktop and offers a fantastic signup bonus of $5,000 and 75 free spins. It uses multiple software providers with top slots and table games from Betsoft, Quickspin, and more. Our review covers everything players need to know. At JokaRoom Casino, hundreds of slot machines are waiting for players who want variety. To do this, JokaRoom Casino has attracted the best software developers. You can count on, for example, the hit “Book of the Dead”, which is currently almost absent from the casino. It’s about an explorer who gets lost in Egypt and searches for a magic book. Help him do that and spin the reels. Would you rather see diamonds instead of magic books? Then you should make your first experience with the Netent Starburst game. This is also an online classic that delights numerous fans. If you are lucky, you can get unique prizes from the colorful shimmering diamonds. Try it, press the power button and the reels will start spinning.

  48. http://mexicanph.shop/# purple pharmacy mexico price list
    reputable mexican pharmacies online [url=http://mexicanph.shop/#]mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs[/url] mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs

  49. https://mexicanph.com/# medication from mexico pharmacy
    mexican mail order pharmacies [url=https://mexicanph.shop/#]purple pharmacy mexico price list[/url] best online pharmacies in mexico

  50. http://mexicanph.shop/# buying from online mexican pharmacy
    mexico drug stores pharmacies [url=http://mexicanph.shop/#]medicine in mexico pharmacies[/url] best online pharmacies in mexico

  51. https://mexicanph.com/# mexican pharmaceuticals online
    п»їbest mexican online pharmacies [url=https://mexicanph.shop/#]medicine in mexico pharmacies[/url] mexico drug stores pharmacies

  52. https://mexicanph.com/# best online pharmacies in mexico
    mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa [url=http://mexicanph.com/#]buying from online mexican pharmacy[/url] best online pharmacies in mexico

  53. http://mexicanph.com/# buying prescription drugs in mexico online
    п»їbest mexican online pharmacies [url=http://mexicanph.com/#]buying from online mexican pharmacy[/url] mexican pharmaceuticals online

  54. mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs mexican pharmacy buying prescription drugs in mexico online

  55. http://mexicanph.shop/# mexico pharmacies prescription drugs
    best online pharmacies in mexico [url=https://mexicanph.com/#]mexico drug stores pharmacies[/url] buying prescription drugs in mexico

  56. http://mexicanph.com/# medicine in mexico pharmacies
    buying from online mexican pharmacy [url=http://mexicanph.shop/#]mexican pharmaceuticals online[/url] mexican rx online

  57. https://stromectol.fun/# where to buy stromectol
    cost of ivermectin medicine [url=http://stromectol.fun/#]ivermectin 3mg for lice[/url] ivermectin buy online

  58. https://furosemide.guru/# furosemide
    purchase stromectol online [url=http://stromectol.fun/#]where to buy ivermectin[/url] ivermectin otc

  59. http://buyprednisone.store/# prednisone canada prices
    buy prednisone 40 mg [url=http://buyprednisone.store/#]prednisone ordering online[/url] 400 mg prednisone

  60. http://buyprednisone.store/# can i buy prednisone online without a prescription
    purchase amoxicillin online [url=https://amoxil.cheap/#]amoxicillin buy canada[/url] purchase amoxicillin online without prescription

  61. https://buyprednisone.store/# mail order prednisone
    minocycline 100 mg capsule [url=https://stromectol.fun/#]where can i buy oral ivermectin[/url] minocycline 100 mg for sale

  62. https://indianph.xyz/# top 10 pharmacies in india
    best india pharmacy [url=http://indianph.com/#]top online pharmacy india[/url] mail order pharmacy india

  63. https://indianph.com/# world pharmacy india
    indian pharmacies safe [url=http://indianph.xyz/#]cheapest online pharmacy india[/url] indian pharmacy paypal

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *